The cons associated with vinyl are that it doesnt hold up to intense heat. James Hardie siding (The HardiZone System) engineered for climate lasts decades whether you live in a hot, freezing, wet or humid area. Both materials are essentially designed to last 50+ years, with the sun and aging surface materials being the most detrimental factor over the long haul. The answer depends on many factors, like the importance you place on durability, aesthetics, maintenance, cost, energy-efficiency, and eco-friendliness. This insulation can help keep your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter, resulting in long-term savings. For a typical American home (2,000 sq.ft of siding), the average total cost can range from $15,000 to $31,000 for standard vinyl siding. HardiePlank will not warp or melt. Standard grade is in the middle and what most homeowners choose. to install. report, fiber cement siding is only second to stone veneer siding at an ROI of 77.6% in the list of top remodeling projects to undertake based on returns. At the same time, vinyl siding is far more flexible than fiber-cement siding, so it can bend without breaking or cracking. While wood siding has unmatched beauty, it is susceptible to sun damage and rot, meaning you must incur additional costs of maintenance and eventually replace it. If you made the investment and wanted to sell your home, would you recoup your money, assuming the siding is in great condition? Weve provided a guide that is specifically focused on this topic. Fiber cement siding has many names, the most notable being. became an appealing alternative to real wood due to its durability and typically comes with a 25-year warranty. The siding imitates wood clapboard, batten, board, or shakes. Johnathan Brewer is a home improvement expert with over two decades of professional experience as a licensed general contractor specializing in kitchen and bath. Total Cost Verdict: based strictly on which option is more budget friendly, vinyl would be a clear winner. Vinyl siding was introduced in the 1960s, quickly becoming an attractive alternative to aluminum siding. The main "ingredient" in vinyl siding is polyvinyl chloride resin or uPVC. View the best blue siding exterior colors and images below and make your decision. Houses with vinyl siding neighboring a burning house will badly warp in response to the adjacent heat. Siding also keeps homes cool during summer. With vinyl, you have significantly more color options. Which Is Best For Your Budget? Before comparing fiber cement and vinyl siding, its important to define both. Vinyl Siding Vs HardiePlank. Vinyl is a product that once it is installed, has very low maintenance. Whereas in conditions of moderately sized hail, fiber cement will hold up better than vinyl. Quality trim though will increase the ROI, to as much as 77% to 90% for any siding replacement. Panels pop out with relative ease and putting in another panel isnt all that challenging for a handy person. If you buy fiber cement siding with a good guarantee and have it installed properly by professionals, it should last 30 years+. There is no doubt about it, the advantages of. According to the 2020 national averages in the Remodeling Cost vs. Value. Installing siding is a great way to insulate your home from losing heat excessively during winter. At the same time, fiber-cement sidings embossing is uniform enough that it will rarely be mistaken for real wood. . Installing siding is a great way to insulate your home from losing heat excessively during winter. At any rate, with the above referenced ROI figures in recent years, (cost-to-value return) this is nearly a push between vinyl and fiber cement, with just a slight edge for fiber cement. does not produce toxins, making it an eco-friendly alternative to vinyl. Heres what you should know when deciding between pre-painted and pre-primed products in Texas. Vertical fiber cement siding from James Hardie creates tall, clean lines. The siding is composed of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. Verdict: Vinyl clearly wins on this factor. 2020 James Hardie provides maintenance. Often, a burning house will affect an adjacent house with vinyl siding. This would seem to indicate clear victory for vinyl siding, until you look at trends. 45921 Maries Road, Suite 100 for their siding that are worth reading to maintain your investment. One of those factors was known as the Joy Score or the enjoyment that homeowners received once the project was completed. coined from the most popular fiber cement siding brand James Hardie. Vinyl siding is more affected by fire and extreme heat than HardiePlank. An annual cleaning to remove dust is more than enough. While vinyl siding may appear cheap to buy, its not. Vinyl siding is far less expensive, both in terms of the product itself and labor costs to install it. Aesthetic Benefits: When installed properly, siding will look great for decades. It will not disintegrate or rot over time. There are several factors to consider in what makes for quality siding. Both materials offer essentially 4 levels of product, ranging from economic to architectural grade or premium grade. Alternatively, we can help you choose the ideal colors, combinations, and style. But lets take a more nuanced approach to this ongoing battle. Whats more, James Hardie fiber cement siding comes in different IV. The siding is composed of cement, sand, and cellulose fibers. Still, any cost savings may not be reflected in the eventual sale of your home: For resale value, HardiePlank is the better choice. Compare this to vinyl, where there are plenty of guides available online to install the product yourself. Neither vinyl nor hardie board offers much insulation on their own, though vinyl can be purchased with built-in insulation giving it an advantage in terms of energy-efficiency. Since it is composed of cement-like materials and wood fibers, it is stronger than vinyl and much less susceptible to wind and weather damage. Fiber Cement is 4th, behind brick, and comes in at 21%. Preventing Silicosis and Death in Construction Workers. Place a barbecue too close to vinyl siding and it will be warped beyond repair. With fiber cement, qualified contractors would be called in to handle any repairs. A single board of HardiePlank, 12 feet long and 8-1/4 inches wide (5/16 inch thick) in the Primed Cedarmill Lap Siding series, costs $10 to $12. Adding foam-backed siding improves Vinyl sidings R-value further (to 1.8 or more). Pumping insulation can also improve the R-value of both sidings. HardiePlank siding is thicker, allowing deeper texturing than vinyl siding. installed. Looking over this data, you can see that vinyl has been the #1 siding material for much of the last decade. The cheapest siding isnt the best. It will make your home appear larger than it really is and vertical siding can be a great way to add architectural detail. How Much More Expensive Is HardiePlank than Vinyl Siding? According to JamesHardie.com, fiber cement wins in a landslide over vinyl. It does not burn, melt, or warp when exposed to heat, though, which is a significant advantage over vinyl siding. Fiber cement is far better than vinyl when it comes to environmental impact. But the fact that fiber cement wins on durability and enjoyment level cant be denied. guidelines One key factor you may be looking for is energy-efficiency for long-term savings. Most housing developments composed of wood-framed houses have OSB (oriented strand board) as exterior sheathing. Typically, panel replacement is the only fix for warped vinyl siding. Because HardiePlank is thicker, it offers deeper texturing than vinyl siding. Serving Northern Virginia, Fairfax County, Prince William County, Loudoun County, Leesburg, Va, Ashburn Va, South Riding,Manassas, Fairfax City, Arlington, and the towns of Vienna, Va and Herndon, Va. Copyright 2022 DryHome Roofing & Siding, Inc. All Rights Reserved Website Development and Marketing by MarketSpark Admin. That said, extremely forceful impacts can cause it to crack. This combination offers notable benefits like resistance to rot, pests, fire, and impact. offers much insulation on their own, though vinyl can be purchased with built-in insulation giving it an advantage in terms of energy-efficiency. This includes window casings, entry ways and corner posts or moldings. HardiePlank, being essentially a long, thin sheet of concrete, will crack upon impact. The Spruce uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. James Hardie Industries considers HardiePlank and all of its fiber-cement products to not be "explosive or flammable. HardiePlank is only considered to be fire-resistant, not fireproof. Vinyl generally does better against high winds but doesnt perform as well against. Engineered Wood Flooring Comparison Guide. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. What you will actually pay varies, but there are. James Hardie is not the only maker of fiber cement siding, but they are by far the most popular. Check our wide range of , were here to help you find the information you need to make the right decision for you, your home, and your budget. Solid Wood vs. Verdict: the maintenance factor clearly favors vinyl siding. Extreme care must be taken since inhaling the dust may result in acute silicosis. Compare that to the 8.9 score that vinyl siding received, and it is very clear that homeowners love their fiber cement siding more than homeowners who went with vinyl siding. Whats more, James Hardie fiber cement siding comes in different. highest ROI for upscale home remodeling projects. Low Cost: Birds that eat insects are rarely interested in either product because neither product harbors the insects that appeal to woodpeckers. Lets explore. No need ever to paint it as the colors are baked into the material.